Current:Home > ScamsControversial Enbridge Line 3 Oil Pipeline Approved in Minnesota Wild Rice Region -Wealth Evolution Experts
Controversial Enbridge Line 3 Oil Pipeline Approved in Minnesota Wild Rice Region
View
Date:2025-04-14 00:51:42
In a unanimous decision, state regulators in Minnesota approved a controversial new pipeline that will increase the flow of tar sands crude oil from Canada to refineries in the United States.
The long-anticipated ruling is a victory for Canadian pipeline owner Enbridge and a significant blow to environmental and Native American advocates who opposed the pipeline through northern Minnesota in a region rich in wetlands and wild rice lakes.
The “certificate of need” granted Thursday by the state’s Public Utility Commission greenlights a replacement for Enbridge’s Line 3, a 1,000-mile pipeline that runs from Hardistry, Alberta, to Superior, Wisconsin. The new Line 3 will have an initial capacity about twice that of the current pipeline, and that volume could be increased and also allow for other increases elsewhere in Enbridge’s cross-border pipeline network.
The exisiting pipeline, built in the 1960s, crosses Native American land, and a state judge recommended in April that the new Line 3 use the same path. However, the commission on Thursday approved Enbridge’s preferred route instead, with some modifications.
While the Enbridge route would skirt the reservations, it would still pass through areas where tribal members harvest wild rice.
“The process kowtowed to corporate interests,” said Tara Houska of Indigenous environmental advocacy group Honor the Earth. “Just because a regulatory body that is supposed to protect Minnesotans didn’t do its job, it doesn’t mean that this is a lost case.”
The Pipeline Would Increase Tar Sands Exports
In anticipation of the decision, pipeline opponents blocked one of the streets outside the Public Utility Commission’s building in St. Paul on Thursday with a sign reading “Expect Resistance.”
When it became clear that the commission would approve the pipeline, Tania Aubid, a member of the Mille Lacs Band of Ojibwe, stood and shouted, “You have just declared war on the Ojibwe!” the Associated Press reported from the scene.
Enbridge spokesperson Jesse Semko declined to comment on the decision, saying the company was waiting until after the hearing.
The new pipeline would allow for a significant increase in exports of Canadian tar sands crude oil, which is difficult to extract, costly to transport and has a high carbon footprint compared to other crude oil. Currently 2.5 million barrels of tar sands crude is exported from Canada each day, and the region has an oil glut exacerbated by years of opposition to building new pipeline capacity.
While the Public Utility Commission’s decision was seen as the last major hurdle before pipeline construction can being in the state, the project still requires various water and soil permits from the state’s Department of Natural Resources and Pollution Control agency as well as the Army Corps of Engineers.
The Army Corps’ permit was the key stamp of approval required in the fiercely contested Dakota Access pipeline from North Dakota to Illinois, a pipeline that began operation in 2017. The Army Corps permit has received little focus in the current pipeline fight as pipeline opponents assume the federal government, under the Trump administration, will approve the project.
“No one is really holding their breath around federal level permits these days,” said Natalie Cook, an organizer with the North Star Chapter of the Sierra Club.
Appeals and the Possibility of Protests
Pipeline opponents could also appeal the commission’s decision.
“There are parties in this case that have lawyers that will continue to fight,” said Brent Murcia, one of thirteen Youth Climate Intervenors, ages 17-25, who oppose the pipeline project over concerns it will further fuel climate change.
From the time it is extracted to the time it is burned, oil flowing through the pipeline would add between 35 and 193 million tons of carbon to the atmosphere each year, according to the project’s environmental impact statement.
“The idea that we would be making a long-term investment in that kind of oil transportation capacity at this moment in our history, it’s not something we can do,” Murcia said.
At least two protest camps near the Line 3 route, including one organized by Honor the Earth, formed in preparation for the Public Utility Commission’s decision. The camps raise the specter of mass demonstrations along the pipeline’s route similar to those that drew thousands to demonstrate against the Dakota Access pipeline near the Standing Rock reservation in 2016 and 2017.
“People are prepared to stand and engage in civil disobedience to protect their homelands and protect their treaty territory,” Houska said. “We will do what it takes.”
veryGood! (557)
Related
- 2025 'Doomsday Clock': This is how close we are to self
- South Korean dog meat farmers push back against growing moves to outlaw their industry
- NASA rocket launch may be visible from 10 or more East Coast states: How to watch
- 'Hero dog' facing euthanasia finds a home after community rallies to get her adopted
- Federal appeals court upholds $14.25 million fine against Exxon for pollution in Texas
- Ed Sheeran serves hot dogs in Chicago as employees hurl insults: 'I loved it'
- Brittney Griner will miss at least two WNBA games to focus on her mental health, Phoenix Mercury says
- Turn Your Favorite Pet Photos Into a Pawfect Portrait for Just $20
- $73.5M beach replenishment project starts in January at Jersey Shore
- How to protect your car from extreme heat: 10 steps to protect your ride from the sun
Ranking
- Juan Soto praise of Mets' future a tough sight for Yankees, but World Series goal remains
- US needs win to ensure Americans avoid elimination in group play for first time in Women’s World Cup
- Death toll rises to 54 after blast at Pakistan political gathering
- Yellow is shutting down and headed for bankruptcy, the Teamsters Union says. Here’s what to know
- What to know about Tuesday’s US House primaries to replace Matt Gaetz and Mike Waltz
- Hi, Barbie! Margot Robbie's 'Barbie' tops box office for second week with $93 million
- Randy Meisner, founding member of the Eagles, dies at 77
- Malala Yousafzai Has Entered Her Barbie Era With the Ultimate Just Ken Moment
Recommendation
What were Tom Selleck's juicy final 'Blue Bloods' words in Reagan family
As the pope heads to Portugal, he is laying the groundwork for the church’s future and his legacy
Britney Spears' Mother-in-Law Hospitalized After Major Accident
Haiti confronts challenges, solutions amid government instability
Trump invites nearly all federal workers to quit now, get paid through September
New Hampshire nurse, reportedly kidnapped in Haiti, had praised country for its resilience
Lori Vallow Daybell sentencing live stream: Idaho woman facing prison for murders of her children
These are the top 10 youngest wealthiest women in America. Can you guess who they are?